Four Signs We’re Possibly in an Animation Bubble Right Now

I’ll be honest, this post was not used as an excuse to post a picture of Bubbles.

Over the past number of years, we’ve slowly seen animation come in from the cold as it were. Yes, Disney has had critical and commercial successes for years, but only within the last 10-15 has anyone else actually stood up and taken notice at just how profitable an animated film is. Not only does it rake in the dollars at the box office, they also tend to have some very long legs. Just look at the Lion King, 17 years old and still going strong.

Which leads to today’s post. With the obvious success of the technique, are we in the midst of an economic bubble in terms of animation? I mean, there is a difference between strong economic growth and unsustainable expansion. The question is are we in one or the other. Here’s 4 reasons for the latter point of view.

1. Revenues aren’t rising as fast as costs

Revenues for animated features have been rising at a relatively steady rate, but they have not risen at the same rate as costs. Naturally this is partly to do with the greater use of technology than in the past. CGI isn’t as cheap to implement as traditional animation, which could be shipped off to Asia for the real labour-intensive work. CGI on the other hand requires a very large upfront investment followed by the costs of the labour to utilise it.

Revenues are not rising at the same rate and the result is squeeze somewhere along the production line that will eventually reach a crunch point.

2. The Number of Players in the Market is Rapidly Growing

It’s elementary economics that once someone discovers a way to make money, at least one other person will attempt to emulate their success. Animation is no different. Today, there are no less than 4 large players (Disney, DreamWorks, Sony, Illumination) in the market and more are being added all the time.

When this becomes a bubble is when you see players who attempt to over-extend themselves into the market. We’re seeing this right now with various one-man bands and VFX studios that have figured they can have a go too. Of course, this is nothing new and has been happening since day dot. The difference is that the rate at which we’re seeing new entrants has substantially increased over the last couple of years. This leads us nicely to….

3. Competition is Becoming Intense

With more players in the market, this leads to increased competition in just about all aspects of the business, from artists, to technology to studio space to release windows. More competition is always welcome as it keeps everyone on their toes and ensures a more efficient use of resources. the only downside is that it also tends to weed out the smaller or inefficient guys.

Why would more competition signal a developing bubble? Well, with an increased demand and scarcer resources, costs for those resources tend to rise. Since competition is increasing at a faster rate than the market is growing, that is indicative of a bubble.

4. The Market is Limited And Changing To Boot

Right now, the market in North America is limited. The market is mature and it’s not getting bigger in the grand scheme of things. The growth markets right now are in Eastern Europe and Asia. the only problem is that those markets tend to have quite distinct cultures, and as a result, aren’t as open to Western films as the rest of the world.

Negating the fact that DreamWorks recently announced that they’re building a studio in China to capitalise on the local market, it’s clear that Western studios face a market with increased competition but not an larger space in which to grow. The result is that we’ll either see reduced revenues or studios being forced to reduce costs. Mark my words, $300 million movies are not sustainable in the long run, at least not right now.

Coupled to this, the changes in the market in general, thanks to the internet, mean that the industry as we know it may be vastly different in a few years time. The rise of streaming, the decline of traditional TV, and the new revenue streams that go along with them means that studios will have to adopt a different tune. Whether they are proactive or not in this regard will surely determine whether we’ll see the bubble burst.

4 thoughts on “Four Signs We’re Possibly in an Animation Bubble Right Now”

  1. Any excuse to post a picture of Bubbles is a good thing.
    I am going to say that animation is both in a bubble and not in a bubble.
    Let’s examine the post in this article:

    1. Revenues aren’t rising as fast as costs
    As you said, this is primary a technology issue. There is no real reason for animation studios to use CGI. The success of the re-issued “Lion King” is proof of this. To audiences, animation is animation. It’s the story that counts. 3D, 2D, CGI, etc are only really important inside the industry itself. 2D is also much better for internet streaming, the future of all media. On top of that, technology has a knack of getting cheaper over time.

    2. The Number of Players in the Market is Rapidly Growing
    You didn’t count all the freelancers that post to sites such as YouTube. The number of players in the market are far greater than the animation itself would admit, and this has been true for at least a decade. The number of players has been increasing since day one, and I doubt it will stop until everyone is doing some animation in some form. You may get fewer that release to say cinema, but that does not mean the others won’t be around.

    3. Competition is Becoming Intense
    Since you haven’t considered the freelancers, you have failed to note that competition has been intense for years. Animation will eventual come highly split into niches, bu,t like every other medium before it, animation will find its purpose.

    4. The Market is Limited And Changing To Boot
    As anyone that does any business online, knowing how to market to the world is important to every venture. Animation is no different. The animation in North America is not tapped out. Most companies have yet to conceive every way to use animation. This will come more apparent as younger demographics get older. Those raise on cartoons will accept animation more really that those that haven’t, and that describes just about everyone under 40-years of age. The market is there for those that want to take risks. Though, there will be many failed experiments along the way.
    Having to research this for my own website, the amount of animation has been exponentially increasing since day one. I don’t see it stopping any time soon. The market is there, and waiting. We have not yet seen how big it is. But, that does not mean growth will come smoothly either.

  2. Pingback: More Evidence Of A Theatrical Animation Bubble - The Animation Anomaly

  3. Pingback: How Animated Films and Cinemas Can Avoid Sliding Into Oblivion | The Animation Anomaly The Animation Anomaly

  4. Pingback: What happens when you've been writing a blog for seven years - The Animation Anomaly The Animation Anomaly

Comments are closed.