Why Frederator Were Right To Pull The Mathematical Video

It doesn’t happen often, but sometimes people make mistakes. which is apparently what happened over on the Adventure Time blog the other day. The show is well known for it’s growing and devoted fan-base that stems from the show’s top quality, it’s quirky and loveable characters, and, most importantly of all, the way the creators, network and studio crafted and actively encouraged the creation of a community around the show.

As part of this, Frederator began putting out two recap video of each episode, one solicited responses from fans, the other contained said responses as art, music, voice messages, etc. The long and the short of the latest video, is that it went out as usual and generated a lot of discussion on the internet before being withdrawn.

The result was that a lot of fans were upset for many reasons, but chief among them is that the felt that Frederator/CN/The Man was somehow censoring some aspect of the show.

This is patently false.

In fact, I’d go so far as to say that it’s almost a smack in the face, especially as plenty of it has continued even after an official explanation. Understandably though, emotions do seem to be running a bit high, especially given the subject matter.

However, there is an extremely valid reason that Fred touched on but did not go into detail on, and it’s the one and only reason the video was pulled.

Here’s why he was right to do so.

In a handy coincidence, I’m right in the middle of reading a book called Remix by Lawrence Lessig (of Creative Commons fame).

Remix by Lawrence Lessig coverIt’s a rather fascinating book that I’d encourage you all to read, you can even download it for free.

In it, Lessig discusses his theory of RO culture and RW culture. RO refers to Read-Only and RW refers to ReWrite. The difference is that the former allows the creator more control over what they create and how it’s consumed and the latter extends the right to anyone should they wish to ‘remix’ it into something new.

As far as RO culture goes, right now that means anything on TV, film and radio where the creators intend for it to be seen/read/heard exactly as they originally intended it. RW culture is pretty much everything outside of that that is primarily created by fans.

Adventure Time is a show in the RO tradition. It is meant to be watched the way that Pen Ward, the studio and network intended it to be. Fans are free to create whatever they wish, however that is all done outside of the official channels and is clearly labelled as such.

What the recent Mathematical video did was inadvertently insert part of the RW culture into an RO show. In other words, it took the context of the Princess Bubblegum/Marceline relationship and implied something that Pen Ward and his crew never intended to be the case. Their vision for the show was compromised and that puts things at odds with the goals of RO culture.

Therefore the video had to be pulled because otherwise it could have compromised how the characters and the show are meant to be viewed by the audience.

Fans are still free to imply whatever they wish because they are part of the RW side of things. They create many new and wonderful things but it is clear they are independent of the show. Frederator is part of the production team and they are obligated to follow the vision of the creators, whatever it is.

The decision has nothing, repeat, nothing to do with the nature of the relationship. That is completely irrelevant to the discussion and it isn’t fair to insinuate that the decision was made based on that and that alone.

Even if crew members engage in creating their take on the relationship, unless it is officially sanctioned, then they too are acting as part of the RW culture, in other words, they are acting outside of the RO culture of the show and their art can’t be seen as ‘official’.

Fred and the studio acted completely correctly in pulling the video because the longer it was left up, the more and more it would have compromised the original vision of the creator, Pen Ward and how he wanted everyone to see the characters.

Irregardless of the potential future developments in the show or its characters, pulling the video was the best decision given the circumstances and all the criticism that is being thrown about is completely unwarranted.

3 Comments on “Why Frederator Were Right To Pull The Mathematical Video

  1. (I apologize for posting this previously on your About page, I didn’t realize that I could comment on the article itself–feel free to delete my other post)

    That was a very interesting post about the “What Was Missing” recap. I’m trying to get caught up on all the latest discussion, and I have a couple lingering questions about the issue that perhaps you can answer.

    1) Did previous recaps diverge from the RO world of Adventure Time (and if so, why did the ax suddenly fall on “What Was Missing”)?

    2) Have there been any official public responses from AT staff, Cartoon Network, etc. that have stated that the recap did not match the creator’s vision?

    Any information you have and your impartial insight would be greatly appreciated!

    • No worries Dee, and I’m sorry for the delay in responding, I was trying to figure out how to move your comment to the right post, but it’s all sorted now 🙂

      1) I haven’t seen all the recap videos, but I would say that they didn’t diverge from the RO world. They may have suggested things, but they were just that, speculations that didn’t imply anything official. “What Was Missing” took those suggestions to a whole new level by veering too close to the “well we don’t know what you thought but here’s what it could be” kind of inclination.

      2) I haven’t read any official responses besides the one on Fred’s blog. That’s the way its likely to stay too because Frederator were the only arm of the production involved with it and are the only ones responsible as a result. I’d say the best indication that the video didn’t match Pen’s vision will come in future episodes. Until then, we’ll just have to presume that the official line stands true.

      Thanks for reading!

  2. While I totally agree with you on the RW/RO-culture problem you defined above I still think that no one would have given a damn if this mix-up of RO/RW would not been about lesbianism.

    No one would have cared – or even noticed – if they had suggested something to be true that isn’t officially part of the Adventure time cosmos but made up by fans if it wasn’t something sexual. Damn, I can’t come up with an example, sorry.

Leave a Response

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Original Content License